ALCOA+ says GMP data must be Attributable, Legible, Contemporaneous, Original and Accurate, plus Complete, Consistent, Enduring and Available. For machine control systems this means: individual user accounts, audit trails that capture every change, synchronised clocks, data saved at the time of the event, original electronic records retained (not just printouts), protected storage with backup, and records available for review throughout retention. Shared logins, disabled audit trails and data only on a local HMI are the classic failures.
ALCOA+ mapped to control systems
| Principle | What it means for PLC, HMI and SCADA |
|---|---|
| Attributable | Unique logins; every action linked to a person |
| Legible | Records readable for their full retention, in reports and exports |
| Contemporaneous | Data written when generated; time stamps from a controlled, synchronised clock |
| Original | First electronic capture retained; printouts are not a substitute for dynamic data |
| Accurate | Calibrated sensors, validated calculations, no unauthorised edits |
| Complete | All data, including failed or aborted runs, with metadata and audit trail |
| Consistent | Sequence of events and time stamps make sense |
| Enduring | Stored on durable, backed-up media |
| Available | Retrievable for review and inspection during retention |
Typical weaknesses on machines
- Generic "operator" or "admin" accounts on HMIs.
- Audit trails disabled, not configured or never reviewed.
- Users able to change the HMI clock or delete batch files.
- Data held only on the HMI and overwritten when memory fills.
- Recipe and setpoint changes not recorded with old and new values.
- USB ports and Windows desktops open to operators.
FDA warning letters regularly cite these under 21 CFR 211.68(b), and inspectors increasingly ask who reviewed the audit trail, not only whether one exists.
Design fixes to specify
- Role-based access with individual accounts, ideally linked to site directory services.
- Non-editable audit trails covering logins, alarms, setpoint and recipe changes, data deletion.
- Central time synchronisation.
- Automatic transfer of batch data to a secure server or historian.
- Locked-down operating system; no desktop access for operators.
- Audit trail review screens and reports that QA can use efficiently.
See also Part 11 checklist and audit trail features.
Companies listed in the Hello Pharma supplier directory
The Hello Pharma supplier directory lists 37 companies relevant to this guide, grouped below by machine type or category. Each name links to the company's directory entry, with a description, technologies, location and website. Companies confirmed against their websites or public listings appear first in each group.
Inclusion is not an endorsement or ranking. Many categories are inferred from company names and segments, so confirm capabilities, approvals and service reach directly with each supplier. Search all 1,232 companies.
Automation and controls (29)
Accupack Engineering Pvt Ltd; Adam Fabriwerk; A.S. Automations; Appidi Technologies Pvt. Ltd.; Avcon Controls Pvt. Ltd.; B&R Industrial Automation Pvt. Ltd.; B.D. Industries; Crystal Automation Pvt. Ltd; Electronics Devices Worldwide Pvt Ltd; Elektrocraft (India) Pvt. Ltd.; Hilda Automation; Inline Technologies; Jay Instruments & Systems Pvt Ltd; Kesar Control Systems; MICROCON; Millenia Technologies; Mitsubishi Electric India Pvt Ltd.; Ngen Controls System; Nord Drivesystems Pvt Ltd; P.M Electro Auto Pvt. Ltd; PRETECH Automation Pvt. Ltd.; Protech Technologies Pvt. Ltd.; Radix Electrosystems Pvt. Ltd.; Saksham Technologies Pvt. Ltd.; Shubham Automation Pvt. Ltd.; Sierra Instrumentation & Controls; Staubli Tec Systems India Pvt Ltd; Sunjay Technologies Pvt Ltd; Toshniwal Instrument Mfg.Pvt.Ltd.
Open the full entries: Automation, inspection and serialization list filtered to automation and controls · Packaging machinery list filtered to automation and controls · Components and spares list filtered to automation and controls · Sterile, injectable and liquid equipment list filtered to automation and controls
Pharma software (8)
Caliber Technologies; Catalogic Technologies LLP; ChemRobotics Private Limited; KAN-THT (India) Pvt. Ltd; Progen ERP Systems (P) Ltd.; Sarjen Systems Pvt Ltd; Sundaram Technologies; ValGenesis (India) Private Limited.
Open the full entries: Automation, inspection and serialization list filtered to pharma software
Frequently asked questions
What does ALCOA+ stand for?
Attributable, Legible, Contemporaneous, Original, Accurate, plus Complete, Consistent, Enduring and Available.
Do PLC-only machines need data integrity controls?
If they generate GMP-relevant data or allow changes to critical parameters, yes. Controls can be on the HMI, SCADA or a connected historian.
Is a printed batch report the original record?
Usually not, if the machine creates electronic data. Guidance expects the original electronic data and metadata to be retained where they are dynamic.
What is the most common data integrity finding on equipment?
Shared logins and disabled or unreviewed audit trails.
Related guides
Sources
- MHRA GXP data integrity guidance and definitions (2018), GOV.UK
- ALCOA+ principles guide, IntuitionLabs
- Current FDA warning letters on IT topics, ECA Academy
- Audit trail review is the new FDA finding, Pharma Now
- FDA warning letter on missing audit trails and raw data review, ECA Academy
This guide is general information to support decisions and is not engineering, validation or regulatory advice for a specific project.
